Peer Review Process
To comply with international publishing standards, our journal employs a double-blind peer review system. JEAL commits to rigorous, high quality review while avoiding unnecessary delays. Our dedicated reviewers agree to provide thoughtful reviews within 14 days after accepting an invitation. We are dedicated to a fair review process and deeply value the contributions of our reviewers in maintaining the journal's quality.
Acceptance Criteria
During the pre-review evaluation by the Editor-in-Chief and the review process by the reviewers, manuscripts are evaluated based on:
- Novelty of Insights: The research article should offer new insights to the field.
- Scientific Rigor: The study should ensure that the methods are conducted with precision, transparency, and accountability.
- Coherence and Clarity: The manuscript should be well-written and logically organized.
- Ethicality: Research must adhere to ethical guidelines, including necessary approvals and ethical use of AI.
- Fitness to the Journal's Scope: The content should align with the journal’s scope and the interest of the journal's readership.
Initial Screening
JEAL uses Turnitin to check submissions for originality. Articles with over 10% similarity are rejected immediately. The Editor-in-Chief reviews submissions for suitability, novelty, and significant contribution. Manuscripts that pass editorial triage are handled by the Editor-in-Chief or an Associate Editor, who assigns two blind reviewers.
Double-blind Peer Review
Articles undergo a double-blind peer review by two experts, ensuring confidentiality of authors’ and reviewers’ identities. Reviewers provide objective feedback without revealing their identities. In cases of split recommendations (e.g., rejection and minor revision) , the Editor-in-Chief or the assigned Associate Editor may invite a third reviewer before a recommendation or a decision is made. Manuscripts that have undergone major revision are returned to the original reviewers, whenever possible, for re-review.
Review of In-house Editorial Submissions and Invited Authors
Manuscripts submitted by JEAL editors or members of JEAL’s editorial advisory board are handled by JEAL editors with no conflict of interest. The submitting editors do not take part in the review process or the decision. They undergo JEAL’s standard double blind review process. Manuscripts of invited authors (e.g., editorials/perspectives papers) are reviewed by at least two JEAL editors or two members of the Editorial advisory board.
Final Decision-Making Authority
After the review, the assigned Associate Editor provides an editorial recommendation to the Editor-in-Chief based on the reviewers’ reports and their own assessment of the manuscript. Manuscripts not assigned to an Associate Editor are evaluated directly by the Editor-in-chief. The Editor-in-Chief has the final authority over all editorial decisions. Acceptance decisions are based solely on JEAL’s acceptance criteria. Administrative, technical, or publishing staff have no role in the final scholarly acceptance of manuscripts.
Review Timeline and Turnaround
The entire peer- review process, including revisions, takes approximately two to five months, depending on the extent of revisions required. The total time from submission to publication is approximately four to seven months, which includes initial screening, peer review, copyediting, and production. This timeline assumes revisions are submitted on time. Revised manuscripts submitted late are scheduled for a later issue.





