Pointing fingers with unclean hands : dealing with corruption in international investment arbitration
Date of Publication
College of Law
Honorable mention, 2018/5th batch
Anacleto Rei A. Lacanilao III
Defense Panel Member
Arthur P. Autea
Vyva Victoria M. Aguirre
Jack Andrew O. Miranda
Jose Manuel Diokno
International investment tribunals face the question of whether a corrupt investor has a legal remedy for breaches of a host stateâ€™s substantial obligations under a bilateral investment treaty. â€˜Respecting the lawsâ€™ provisions of BITs limit the cover of protection to investments made in accordance with the respective laws of a host state. Corruption or bribery is therefore a defense that may be invoked to defeat an investorâ€™s claim. The problem with this is that an equally corrupt host state gets a free ticket to escape liability.
Corruption should not be an absolute defense that will preclude admissibility of claims and jurisdiction of tribunals because it operates to exculpate an equally guilty host state involved in corrupt acts. A â€˜cleansed handsâ€™ approach balances the legitimate expectation of investors and the interest of host states consistent with anti-corruption policy in international public policy. In the face of apparent or alleged corruption, where both parties have engaged in corrupt conduct, their illegality operates to â€˜temporarily cleanse both guilty handsâ€™ as to surpass the jurisdictional and admissibility hurdle so that a tribunal will be able to fully evaluate the claims and defenses during the merits stage.
Based on a survey of existing BIT provisions on anti-corruption, the Slovakia- Iran BIT proves to be an ideal starting point for states interested in incorporating anti-corruption provisions in their BITs. In the Slovakia-Iran BIT, consent is explicitly stated and clearly delineated, and it presents a more comprehensive guideline for tribunals dealing with claims involving corruption.
Archives, The Learning Commons, 12F Henry Sy Sr. Hall
81 leaves ; 28 cm. + 1 computer disc 4 3/4 in.
Corruption -- Law and legislation -- Philippines; Investments; Foreign -- Law and legislation -- Philippines
Laureta, M. (2018). Pointing fingers with unclean hands : dealing with corruption in international investment arbitration. Retrieved from https://animorepository.dlsu.edu.ph/etd_honors/393